Eyes on Final Fantasy Forums > Reference > General Archive > Mafia > Mafia V: Official game thread (Day 7 - Game Over. Town Win!)

[[M] Voldemort]

Let me start by saying, when you held the game the PMs said "Town" and "Scum" so how you would have run the game holds no ground. I asked what Cid was, instead I got Edgar: Innocent.

Continuing, you pointing out I didn't investigate Firion which would've possibly confirmed a Mafian. Investigating Cid had the possibilty to do the same, if not more. If I had investigated Cid, and it bounced on to Firion, it would've been game over, we would've had a huge boost in information, so I still consider my choice the correct one.

Moving on, you claim I'm the mafian cop, because either that or Beloved Princess is in the game. Where I agree a mafian cop is more likely then a Beloved Princess, you forget its also possible that your the cop, which is why you can say so calmly Vivi doesn't have a gun.

I also like, how all of your plans include you and Firion surviving till next round. Reviewing everything, I found it hard to choose between Cid, that is true, I chose Cid just to see if I could get lucky and kill two birds with one stone (my investigation bouncing to Firion). So Vivi really shouldn't be my suspect, because now that I think of it, I doubt Psychotic would let a mafian member be THAT inactive. That means Firion, and Rinoa are my two top suspects, and all of your plans have both of you lasting til next round.

Next round will have four people, if you are both mafia, then if you both survive this round then we lose.

Expanding on that idea both of you where in such a rush to vote and get me killed. My theory is that is because you know that if one person falls for it, agrees, then the mafia wins.

I don't think you'll be changing my opinion anytime soon.

## Vote: Rinoa

EDITGA: If you are the only mafian Rinoa, you've covered your butt pretty good. You remembered to mention "If Edgar is a normal cop lynch me next round." Guess what, I already know what you'll say next round, "WHAT A SECOND! I forgot there's a chance we aren't told if someone is a naive cop! Oh well, we should lynch _______________, instead because _________________"

[[M] Hermione Granger]

Well guys, there you have it. It's up to whether you believe Edgar or myself.

Please notice that Edgar focused more on defending himself while I am trying to present scenarios and paths that you guys could go down. Notice he chose to focus on the one scenario where lynching him is bad for the town. Notice now how he is only presenting ideas of how I am Mafia and leaving Vivi out of the equation.

If you lynch me, the town still has a chance of winning if there is only one mafia left. If for some reason you decide to do that, I implore you to lynch Edgar next round.

My role has no further use. Edgar has a gun whether he be cop or mafia. I am not afraid to die as I believe there is only one mafia left. Edgar. But I'd rather you did it today rather than tomorrow in case there is more than one.

I don't feel like arguing much any more, as I know who Edgar is and how much he loves to argue, so that's why I'm choosing not to directly address many of his points (which do have flaws, maybe you can figure them out for yourself). See day 1 for what I am talking about.

[[M] Rubeus Hagrid]

This is how I see it going down, My beard trusts Del Rinoa, I simply cant see someone who is Mafia going after two people who aren't mafia like she did. I say we go after Edgar today, over the night, if we don't win today and assuming Rinoa isn't killed during the night, Del Rinoa sees if Firion has a gun. I think this is the safest way of looking at things.

Edit: Vivi where are you!

##Vote: Edgar

[[M] Ginny Weasley]

Vivi to the rescue!

*casts meteor*

[[M] Rubeus Hagrid]

Now that you have graced us with you presence oh short one, would you please offer your input?

[[M] Ginny Weasley]

I could come up with something, but a lot has already been said. However I would say remember other players like Firion and Quina, there have been some stuff against them I think.

Look guys, I did more than one sentence!

EDIT: lol Quina is dead, nevermind.

[[M] Bellatrix Lestrange]

I really don't know who to vote at this moment. But, my gut instinct - which has been wrong so many times, it's a wonder why I still listen to it - says to go with Edgar as a vote. If he does end up being innocent, then we'll get Rinoa tomorrow. It'd be the same if I was to vote Rinoa, and they ended up being innocent - I'd vote Edgar the next day.

Sorry Edgar, but...

##Vote: Edgar

[[M] Harry Potter]

Edgar showed up at the police department for work, like he always did. He had a busy day of eating donuts and stuffing weasels into his pants ahead of him. He had just finished his morning nap when an angry mob showed up outside, calling for his head.

Edgar would not go down willingly. Shots were fired from the windows, as Edgar screamed that they would never take him alive. He was an officer of the law, and this was anarchy!

The town could not break into the police station. So, waiting outside, they summoned some help.

Enter your dashing hero, Bahamut. The great dragon descended from the heavens, and obliterated Edgar and the police station with a mighty Mega Flare.

Edgar, Mafia Cop, was played by leader of mortals & Goldenboko.

Game over. Your winners: Aeris, Cid, Firion, Rinoa.

And what of Vivi? Well, he dropped down dead soon afterwards. His mission was a failure. You see, Vivi was a Jester