Mafia - Second Edition - Game Over! - Page 25

[M] Kirby · 11-05-2007, 07:56 PM

Originally Posted by Cinderella ^

fyi mafia pretty sure Bambi is the Jester. Pop 'im. We all know the newbie who doesn't understand the game thing is an act, and I was happy to go along with it while you were keeping it up, but now you're turning on me, smurf you, I'll do the same back to you.

leave me alone, maybe your the jester

[M] Kofi Annan · 11-05-2007, 07:57 PM

Originally Posted by Cinderella ^

Oh, and I know you've been aching to vote for me ever since Peter Pan put the suggestion down, but have been struggling to think of a decent reason (still haven't thought of one, fyi) so don't play the "I only just decided!" card.

Now you're using personal attacks. Classy.

And yes, I actually did just decide. Up until a couple of minutes ago I wasn't sure and was watching more posts in this thread to see how things developed. Were you a possible candidate for a vote from me? Yes. Were you the candidate I had picked out to vote for? No.

[M] Bahamut · 11-05-2007, 07:58 PM

My dear, you're being highly prickly and it isn't doing you any favours.

Thinking a bit more...

[M] Slowpoke · 11-05-2007, 08:00 PM

What do you mean "Now"? I've been doing it all along. Ironically enough, though, you picked one of the few things that I've said that wasn't a personal attack. I'm calling you out on your lie, and I hope other citizens realise that you're deceitful.

fyi calling me classy in a sarcastic manner is a personal attack.

Originally Posted by Simba

My dear, you're being highly prickly and it isn't doing you any favours.

Oh, I know it isn't.

YOU BIG FAT LION JERK.

[M] Tonks · 11-05-2007, 08:02 PM

Anyone who has any thoughts of the last game in their mind when playing this one is stupid. The last game should have absolutely no relevance to this one whatsoever, completely different set of people, roles and characters.

Also find it amusing that people are saying "Well X has done this like Y did last time and Y was a mafia, therefore X is mafia as well". In case you've all forgotten, the mafia last time lost, quite severely, and if you're all going to underestimate the mafia to be so stupid as to do what the last ones did, then you're on route to a hiding.

[M] Slowpoke · 11-05-2007, 08:05 PM

Originally Posted by Chip ^

Anyone who has any thoughts of the last game in their mind when playing this one is stupid. The last game should have absolutely no relevance to this one whatsoever, completely different set of people, roles and characters.

Also find it amusing that people are saying "Well X has done this like Y did last time and Y was a mafia, therefore X is mafia as well". In case you've all forgotten, the mafia last time lost, quite severely, and if you're all going to underestimate the mafia to be so stupid as to do what the last ones did, then you're on route to a hiding.

See, Robin Hood? That's how you make a critique on someone's reasoning. You don't use it as a veil to vote for them. (SORRY IF YOU TAKE THIS AS A PERSONAL ATTACK

)

Criticism accepted, Chip.

[M] Rinoa · 11-05-2007, 08:06 PM

PMS much, m'dear? You're being very defensive of yourself. You're also not looking at other people's posts, just mine. Everyone has made a valuable point for other mafia suspects. Honestly, because you are being so defensive, I am inclined to believe that you are just a townsperson trying to stay in the game as long as you can and shaking off anything we find suspicious and getting us to go after someone else, me, to defend yourself. Happy? Someone is defending you for once.

I see nothing wrong with Peter, why on earth would mafia kill their own so early in the game?

[M] Tonks · 11-05-2007, 08:08 PM

Originally Posted by Mickey ^

I see nothing wrong with Peter, why on earth would mafia kill their own so early in the game?

Because it would be a very clever tactic to garner trust around certain people, if done correctly.

Unfortunately, Peter isn't smart enough to pull something like that off.

[M] Kirby Mafia Townsperson	#193 Originally Posted by Cinderella ^ fyi mafia pretty sure Bambi is the Jester. Pop 'im. We all know the newbie who doesn't understand the game thing is an act, and I was happy to go along with it while you were keeping it up, but now you're turning on me, smurf you, I'll do the same back to you. leave me alone, maybe your the jester
11-05-2007, 07:56 PM

[M] Bahamut Mafia Townsperson	#195 (permalink) My dear, you're being highly prickly and it isn't doing you any favours. Thinking a bit more...
11-05-2007, 07:58 PM

[M] Tonks Mafia Townsperson	#200 (permalink) Originally Posted by Mickey ^ I see nothing wrong with Peter, why on earth would mafia kill their own so early in the game? Because it would be a very clever tactic to garner trust around certain people, if done correctly. Unfortunately, Peter isn't smart enough to pull something like that off.
11-05-2007, 08:08 PM