Official Lost Season 4 Thread - Page 18

Flying Mullet · 03-03-2008, 02:12 PM

Originally Posted by Sergeant Hartman ^

just who is the friend on the boat?

I'm still betting on Michael. Although Miles has a good chance too.

Loony BoB · 03-03-2008, 03:23 PM

Originally Posted by Roto13 ^

I don't like time travel. This makes me a sad panda.

I'd hate it if it were one of those "You can meet yourself in the future!" things, but this consciousness living outside the chronological life of his body is a bit more allowable.

Having said that, I'm not keen on anything that is a paradox as it opens up for too much that is beyond reason. One thing I've always liked about Lost is that even if things are beyond belief (eg. people coming back to life, ghosts talking, etc) it is still kept within some kind of laws of reason (ie. you can't change the past and remember both pasts). I hope that it's explained in a more believable manner. I mean, the whole "constant" thing - how does that work? This is getting to the point that it's more magical fantasy than science fiction and I hope it won't go completely down that route.

I'm my own MILF · 03-03-2008, 05:30 PM

I don't understand criticism of the constant. People seem fairly willing to accept psychic temporal projection or whatever it is, but the idea that knowing something in both time periods can help you keep your bearings is beyond the pale?

McLovin' · 03-03-2008, 06:25 PM

I believe there will be a logical explanation xD

Germ Hamee · 03-03-2008, 09:19 PM

Funny, I thought the constant idea was pretty much the most logical thing this show has ever done.

scrumpleberry · 03-03-2008, 10:45 PM

I quite enjoyed this episode, particularly because I thought the time travel was well done.

I rolled my eyes quite a lot at the Des/Penny bit at the end, but it was cute all the same. I love Desmond, even if he is becoming a Mary-Sue along with Sayid. Elouise made me sad D:

Originally Posted by Psychotic ^

I'm rewatching Season One right now. Psychic guy telling Claire that her baby must be raised by her and nobody else made me think of the situation that was revealed in the episode before last with Kate. Uh-oh.

ZOMG PSY I JUST HAD A ZOMG MOMENT WHEN YOU SAID THAT THANK YOU THANK YOU.

pee.ess: Kate is getting repetitive with her LUV TRIANGLES, CAN SHE STAY PUT??? I agree.

Sergeant Hartman · 03-03-2008, 10:50 PM

Originally Posted by Flying Mullet ^

Originally Posted by Sergeant Hartman ^

just who is the friend on the boat?

I'm still betting on Michael. Although Miles has a good chance too.

Yeah I was thinking it might be him, I wanna see a Michael episode now.

Sarc the Swordsman · 03-04-2008, 01:33 AM

Interesting episode. Although I haven't seen much of her, I really like Penny Widmoore. I don't think Daniel, Frank and Charlotte are bad guys though. Miles seems to be though.

Flying Mullet Site Staff Cid's Knight this space for rent Location: Finding my monkey cage exit strategy	#137 Originally Posted by Sergeant Hartman ^ just who is the friend on the boat? I'm still betting on Michael. Although Miles has a good chance too.
03-03-2008, 02:12 PM

I'm my own MILF I shall watch over you. Location: Augustgrad	#139 (permalink) I don't understand criticism of the constant. People seem fairly willing to accept psychic temporal projection or whatever it is, but the idea that knowing something in both time periods can help you keep your bearings is beyond the pale?
03-03-2008, 05:30 PM

McLovin' I am Mclovin! ~ 2007 Location: can you be more specific?	#140 (permalink) I believe there will be a logical explanation xD
03-03-2008, 06:25 PM

Germ Hamee I'm better on the carpet! Location: Lone Tree, Colorado	#141 (permalink) Funny, I thought the constant idea was pretty much the most logical thing this show has ever done.
03-03-2008, 09:19 PM

Sergeant Hartman Funk It Location: on a higher plane	#143 (permalink) Originally Posted by Flying Mullet ^ Originally Posted by Sergeant Hartman ^ just who is the friend on the boat? I'm still betting on Michael. Although Miles has a good chance too. Yeah I was thinking it might be him, I wanna see a Michael episode now.
03-03-2008, 10:50 PM

Sarc the Swordsman Location: England	#144 (permalink) Interesting episode. Although I haven't seen much of her, I really like Penny Widmoore. I don't think Daniel, Frank and Charlotte are bad guys though. Miles seems to be though.
03-04-2008, 01:33 AM