Eyes on Final Fantasy Forums > General > Artist's Forum > Graphic Design Forum > Harry potter sig.. and some others..

[Tommygunfeth]

lol..
harry potter ftw:


and my WoW-sig:


my 3D lightsaber-sig:


old Sasuke-sig:



there.. won't post anymore now..

please give some critique

[Owen Macwere]

Ok, i am going to give good comments from now on, you are the first, be ready.



This one is a bit long and empty, maybe you should have used a bigger picture of harry and made the sig thinner. text too plain.



This one is good with the blending, the using of filters is good as well, better way to learn graphics is playing with filters. Text alot better in this one, but the whole sig is a bit too sharp.



can't comment unless I know if this is an image that you just resized or if you really created it. so?.



Looks good, blending and text are well done, but a bit too empty could have used some more effects.

Over all you did a nice work, keep at it, and by the way, what program do you use?.

[Tommygunfeth]

Hi there.. thanks for the comment

Well.. on the daniel radcliffe sig I totally agree with you.. it's too long and too much space.

On the WoW sig being too sharp, well, I know this and that's kind of what I wanted. And, this is not filters.. it's texturing and brushing..

On the 3D sig, yes I made it in Cinema 4D

Sasuke sig is a little empty, but me.. I'm all about minemalistic, less is more.. I don't want to overcrowd the sig with stocks..

And for programs I use Photoshop CS2, and Cinema 4D if I wanna do a little 3D..

[Owen Macwere]

I see, try to get some new brushs and play with filters and smudging next time. I like the telescope one very much, great work with C4D. About overcrowding the sig, you wont overcrowd it if you use the right effects for the right image.

[Tommygunfeth]

how long have you been doing this?

and.. it's actually a lightsaber:P lol

and "playing" with filters.. I normally don't do that.. I do what I have to do, I'm sort of aware what the filters do when I use them..
So if I want an effect I know what to do..

[Owen Macwere]

I see, ok. But you wanted comments and I gave you my thoughts. =P
I been using Photoshop for eight months now. And by effects I don't mean stone effect or something that is done one way, I mean how to make the effect flow with your sig. Anyway, keep at what you are doing.

[Tommygunfeth]

Originally Posted by Owen Macwere ^

I see, ok. But you wanted comments and I gave you my thoughts. =P
I been using Photoshop for eight months now. And by effects I don't mean stone effect or something that is done one way, I mean how to make the effect flow with your sig. Anyway, keep at what you are doing.

I just think we have quite a different style.
I've been doing graphics/film/music etc for over 3 years.. I'm even studying it..
anyways.. I wanted comments on them so yeah, thank you
these sig's are pretty old though.. The newest one is the WoW sig which I did in 5 min to just have a cool sig on a WoW forum.. And I made it a couple months ago.. I don't really do alot of designing now, I focus more on film and music

+Im sorry if I seemed rude.. didn't mean that..

[Seppuku]

Why is Harry Potters face so far over?