Eyes on Final Fantasy Forums > General > Artist's Forum > Graphic Design Forum > Rate the Set Above You. - You may post only once for every ten posts.

[~Megalixir~]

Avi- 5.5/10 It has a border! *Gasp*
Sig- 5/10 it looks.. honestly, boring. But if it had color it might get higher rating

[Rengori]

OOC:	At least wait the ten freaking posts.

[Rye]

I'll give you a real rating, Rengori, since you missed out on one.

I love the drawing, I think it was very well done. I'd recommend a thin line border, but that's about it. I like the lack of colour. 8/10

[~Megalixir~]

OOC: I dont go by rules.

[Miriel]

~Megalixir~, cut it out. This thread is for seriously evaluating signatures, not for making glib remarks and disregarding the rules. This is a warning, don't do it again.

While I'm here, I'll give Rye a rating.

Signature - 9/10 - I love the stuff you been coming out with recently. The textures on this one is fantastic. And the smoothness of the picture on the left side works so well with the textures that surrounds it. I know you like the monotone color thing for your sig, but maybe experiment with have more than one main color?

Avatar - 8/10 - I like the area of your sig that you chose to single out and put into your avatar but I don't really like the borders.

[Evastio]

So whose sig and avatar am I suppose to rate?

I guess I'll rate Rye's.

I don't know what's in the avatar. I like the transparency effect though. I like the brightening effect that occurs at the top-right corner of your sig.

Avatar: 7/10
Sig: 7/10

[Chris]

Pretty simple, but it works. Sometimes less is more, and your sig clearly understates that. I like it.

Oh yeah, before the next person says "It's just a pic," it is NOT! I made it from scratch.

[Roto13]

I have no idea who that is, but it's got an interestingly simple style to it, and it's small and not obnoxious. 9.5/10 for the set, since it's the same picture for both.