Eyes on Final Fantasy Forums > General > Artist's Forum > Graphic Design Forum > Rate the Set Above You. - You may post only once for every ten posts.

[Setzer Gabianni]

Avatar - 6/10 - It's cute, but it is just a smilie so..6/10 will have to do.

Sig - 6/10 - Looks like the image is just stuck there, but the background seems to fit it well. Don't like the text, but the sig gets marks for Sephiroth being there.


For those rating mine, I'm guessing you won't know who the guy in my sig is - if not, I would prefer it if you didn't rate it lowly because you don't know the character xD - if you get what I mean o_o

~Setzer Gabbiani

EDIT: What I meant was, I ain't sure how familiar people are with FFXII o_o

[Owen Macwere]

People don't rate a sig for the charcter in it, they rate it according to the effects, text, BG..etc.
anyway, sig: 8/10.. I don't like the text used and it goes over his face.
avy: 9/10, nice cut.

[Tempest]

I like your new siggy Owen although it's kind of bright for my tastes. 8/10

Your avatar is pretty cool and darker. So it gets a 10.

[Chibi Youkai]

I like your signature, although I'm not the hugest pink fan, i think it's wrong to base things on personal prefrences. The abstact design is done well, and fits together, even though I'm not sure what it is in the upper right corner. 10/10

avvy, a cut, but it looks really good. 10/10

for refrence, the characters in mine are sue and feena from the origional grandia.

[Genji]

Sig: Happy and cheerful. Nice picture, and I like the sun. 8/10 because the grass doesn't look all that good.

Avvy: Matches, and its not a cut. 10/10

[Ramza Beoulve]

Great sig there Genji, I like the FFVIII effect for the sig parts 9/10

The avatar is just an image of quetzacotl though, a good one, but just an image... 6.5/10

[Rase]

Avatar: Interesting. It's nice to see an avatar that isn't a square. I like the dark red lines over the lighter red, and the flashing text is a neat touch. 8/10

Signature: That's an absolutely beautiful picture of Amaterasu from Ōkami. I also like how you used the same basic shape as in your avatar, but kept the text from being too intrusive on the sig itself. Easily one of my favorite sigs currently on the forums, it's just so pleasing to look at. 10/10

[Rengori]

AVATAR: Awesome sprite dude. 10/10
SIG: It's interesting to say the least. 9/10

On another note, why do people say, "sprite sigs don't impress me," when a crapload of sigs are using the same render of Cloud pushing his goggles up or Sephiroth walking through a fire?