Eyes on Final Fantasy Forums > Reference > Feedback Forum > Eyes on's Next Cid's Knight

[Levian]

Originally Posted by Roto

I think if you can't stand losing, don't enter a competition with 69 other people. Seriously. The odds of winning are slim. People who can't take rejection need to just stop doing anything.

Yeah, seriously.

Originally Posted by Spuuky ^

I think the idea was good, it was just fatally flawed by the fact that all the people who should be staff members either already are or don't want to be. :C

Weird that you'd even call it a good idea to begin with if you believed that flaw to be true. It'd be a pretty horrible idea if it was. I think lots of good candidates signed up for this competition.

That said, I think it was an excellent idea. As someone said, it was a much needed breath of life into the community, as well as it might've opened some staff eyes regarding good staff candidates out there.

[Roto13]

I'm sure I wouldn't have even been considered if not for the contest. :P

Edit: Also, WTF is with immunities. If they fail a challenge they fail. A person should never be given immunity. If they aren't qualified, they shouldn't be allowed to advance, period.

Yeah, that's kind of my school of thought, too. I didn't want to actually win the immunity challenges because it means nothing to be immune for one round. :P That said, it doesn't look like they'll really matter by the end.

[Pureghetto]

Originally Posted by Roto13 ^

Yeah, that's kind of my school of thought, too. I didn't want to actually win the immunity challenges because it means nothing to be immune for one round. :P That said, it doesn't look like they'll really matter by the end.

I didn't mind the immunities. For a brief period of time (due to real life issues) I felt I "needed" to win an immunity, but never really made it a priority to win. A CK should win on his/her own merits, and it shows in the end that this was the case.

[Heath]

Originally Posted by NeoCracker ^

Edit: Also, WTF is with immunities. If they fail a challenge they fail. A person should never be given immunity. If they aren't qualified, they shouldn't be allowed to advance, period.

The staff could just eliminate them in the next round anyway so they'll end up going out just a bit later. I think there were only immunities for the first and second rounds anyway, so people would only manage to get into the around the last 30 or so anyway. It's not like someone could win the thing based on just immunities.

[edczxcvbnm]

Originally Posted by Roto13 ^

I think if you can't stand losing, don't enter a competition with 69 other people. Seriously. The odds of winning are slim. People who can't take rejection need to just stop doing anything.

I thought this was a good idea until edczxcvbnm lost. I am completely serious.

ed was being a dick to the other contestants and his threads for round four were all about how much he hated the games he was posting about. He'd make a better troll than a CK if that's how he's going to behave. He probably would have made it to the last round if not for that kind of behaviour. But then, if he was really serious about it, he probably wouldn't have done those things in the first place, and if he's not serious about wanting to be a CK, he shouldn't be one.

:o I don't recall any hate in my general gaming or Crono thread. Stop being so bitter and one sided! See the whole picture of fun =D Also...It could have been far far worse(and way more humorous) as demonstrated here Final Fantasy Versus XIII: Holy **** this is a trainwreck - Modojo Community ;D

[Flying Mullet]

I don't mind immunities in the earlier rounds when there's 50-71 contestants as there's so many people that immunizing a couple people isn't going to prevent someone that really deserves a chance a space to move on.

But once you get down to 30 or less candidates I do believe that everyone should advance on their own merits.

Plus, some of the immunities were fun. Although they should have been held for longer periods of time rather than "First five people to be on at arbitrary time will have a chance at immunity."

[rubah]

that's why mine was a mix of chance *and* skill

[Roogle]

Originally Posted by NeoCracker ^

However I don't really notice the forums being any Livelier then normal, but I am a pessimist after all.

Activity has increased in the forums for a certain demographic of users. The nature of the event allows only for registered users to participate and has little chance to entice unregistered users to participate.

Originally Posted by NeoCracker ^

Edit: Also, WTF is with immunities. If they fail a challenge they fail. A person should never be given immunity. If they aren't qualified, they shouldn't be allowed to advance, period.

I believe that the immunities were added to the event to emulate the feel of a reality television show.