Eyes on Final Fantasy Forums > Reference > Feedback Forum > This is me just being picky but~

[Azar]

Advent Children's forum has a pretty substantial number of posts compared to the rest of the faming fora. Not much argument for Dirge of Cerberus, though.

[Avarice-ness]

Originally Posted by Tavrobel ^

Why were they not just made subforums in the first place? Neither the games nor the movie was quite successful enough to be made into their own forum. FFVII --> Compilation sounds best.

Well, AC and DC did have a good amount of hype, Saddly for AC that hype ended a nice time ago, and those excited about DC... well.. they bought the game. Kidding, I think it just didn't have the flare people in the beginning hoped it would. I can say I roamed DC when I thought it was all the cool beans.


@Crisis Core idea: Seeing as the game's due in America in a month and 26 days, I guess you could look at the hype within the FFVII forum to judge what exactly you guys should do with it. I mean, usually for games with a good amount of excitement or hype, there's threads here almost before the japanese release. If anything, there could be a vote in the FFVII forum to decide, kind of like the FFX-2 description thread.

[Roogle]

Originally Posted by crono_logical ^

Roogle: Why does a forum existing for another domain mean it needs to be at the top level anyway?

Because that was the way that the site owner wanted it.

[Momiji]

Originally Posted by Avarice-ness ^

Originally Posted by Big D ^

I'd also prefer to see AC and DC (heh) as sub-forums of FFVII. Same for Crisis Core, when it eventually warrants its own forum. The FFVII forum description would need to be altered to say something about "incorporating Advent Children, Dirge of Cerberus and Crisis Core".

I think it should say "Now offering those pesky spin-off's" but that's just me.

I agree. Merge them all together. FFVII is way overrated anyway.

Note: I'm also all for merging the X and X-2 forums together as well, seeing that they are directly related to each other.

[Roto13]

Stick 'em in the FF VII forum and then delete it, I say.

[Tavrobel]

Originally Posted by Momiji ^

Note: I'm also all for merging the X and X-2 forums together as well, seeing that they are directly related to each other.

Yeah but the difference between FFX and FFX-2 is that one of them sucks, and the other one is godly. That being said, these two games should not be merged; plot points found in FFX-2 can be construed as almost completely contradictory, and the theory of how the world of FFX operates is failed by FFX-2. It is so bad, that it crosses the line of retcon. It is just plain bad story telling.

Alternatively, we could just delete the FFVII forum in its entirety, and make space for two FFVI forums. One is for Zozo, and the other is for Jidoor. They can declare war and it will all be funny funny happy happy. I'll be on the sidelines, watching with a bucket of popcorn as the Zoz-- *sniped*

[Momiji]

Originally Posted by Tavrobel ^

Originally Posted by Momiji ^

Note: I'm also all for merging the X and X-2 forums together as well, seeing that they are directly related to each other.

Yeah but the difference between FFX and FFX-2 is that one of them sucks, and the other one is godly. That being said, these two games should not be merged; plot points found in FFX-2 can be construed as almost completely contradictory, and the theory of how the world of FFX operates is failed by FFX-2. It is so bad, that it crosses the line of retcon. It is just plain bad story telling.

Alternatively, we could just delete the FFVII forum in its entirety, and make space for two FFVI forums. One is for Zozo, and the other is for Jidoor. They can declare war and it will all be funny funny happy happy. I'll be on the sidelines, watching with a bucket of popcorn as the Zoz-- *sniped*

Yeah, good point. FFX was pretty good (but ruined in my eyes by the fanatics), but X-2 was garbage, and I'm happy I didn't buy it when it came out (I bought it used, without the box or anything, for like 5 dollars, which is more than what this piece of garbage is worth).

And I totally agree with the second statement as well!

[Avarice-ness]

Originally Posted by Tavrobel ^

Alternatively, we could just delete the FFVII forum in its entirety, and make space for two FFVI forums. One is for Zozo, and the other is for Jidoor. They can declare war and it will all be funny funny happy happy. I'll be on the sidelines, watching with a bucket of popcorn as the Zoz-- *sniped*

I approve!

Although on the FFX-2 and X merging. Personally, you can't cut out the fact that FFX-2 IS infact tied to FFX in more ways then one. That would basically help the argument of leaving FFVII:AC and DC up, FFVII was awesome, FFVII:AC was cool for the time and DC well.. just stunk.

I think FFX-2 would be made a subforum if anything, but the forum is still active and has no real reason to be put in subforum.

The FFVII argument was because the DC and AC stay dead for long periods at a time, and FFX-2 doesn't follow that guide line.